Sally’s Apizza
If pizza rivalries were a competitive sport, New Haven would have its own ESPN channel. Founded in 1938 by Salvatore “Sally” Consiglio, Sally’s Apizza has been serving its signature pies for generations. And here’s where the family drama comes in: Sally was the nephew of Frank Pepe, whose namesake pizzeria is just down the street.
Over the decades, Sally’s has attracted famous fans, from Frank Sinatra and John F. Kennedy to the Clintons, Gordon Ramsay, and Gwyneth Paltrow. Apparently, celebrities also appreciate a good charred crust.
Inside, the wood-paneled walls, brown leather booths, and Tiffany-style stained-glass pendant lamps give the space a wonderfully old-school feel. It’s like stepping into a time capsule, only with much better food than whatever was being served at your neighborhood mall in 1985. The thin crust and rich sauce make it easy to understand why people have been fiercely loyal to Sally’s for nearly 90 years.
What to Order
- Potato and Rosemary Pie: A white pie with thinly sliced potatoes and rosemary.
- Tomato Sauce Pie: Sally’s signature tomato sauce with Parmesan.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
You can’t talk about New Haven pizza without talking about Frank Pepe. That would be like discussing the Beatles and casually forgetting Paul McCartney.
Founded in 1925 by Frank Pepe and his wife, Filomena, the pizzeria began with bread dough topped with tomatoes, Pecorino, garlic, oregano, and olive oil, a combination that would become part of New Haven’s culinary identity.
But the pie that really put Pepe’s on the map? The White Clam Pizza, which arrived in the 1960s. Fresh clams, garlic, oregano, grated Pecorino Romano, and olive oil come together on a charred crust. No red sauce. No mozzarella avalanche. Just a briny, garlicky masterpiece.
With Sally’s just down the street, the question of who serves the better pie has divided New Haven pizza lovers for decades. People have opinions. Strong ones. The kind usually reserved for politics, sports teams, and whether pineapple belongs on pizza.
Expect lines at both places, especially during peak hours. But consider it part of the experience.
What to Order
- White Clam Pie: The signature pie with fresh clams, garlic, oregano, Pecorino Romano, and olive oil.
- Broccoli Rabe Pie: Grated cheese, broccoli rabe, garlic, and a drizzle of olive oil.
Zeneli Pizzeria e Cucina
Not every pizza in New Haven needs to be thin, charred, and served with a side of century-old rivalry.
Opened in 2019, practically across the street from Frank Pepe’s, Zeneli serves the pillowy, airy crusts of Naples.
The restaurant was founded by four Albanian brothers who trained in pizza-making in Naples before bringing their expertise to the United States. Their dough proofs overnight before hitting an oven that reaches roughly 800°F, where each pie cooks in just minutes.
The result? A soft, puffed crust with that signature Neapolitan chew, a change of pace from the coal-fired classics down the street.
The restaurant has earned recognition from 50 Top Pizza multiple times, and its intimate, welcoming trattoria atmosphere invites you to linger.
What to Order
- Marinara: A classic, cheese-free Neapolitan pie with tomato sauce, garlic, oregano, basil, and extra virgin olive oil.
- Margherita: San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil.
Gioia
What if your neighborhood pizza spot also had an Italian market, a rooftop cocktail bar, and a gelateria? Sounds like a place I’d gladly move into. Welcome to Gioia, a four-in-one Italian playground making its own impression on historic Wooster Street.
Gioia is the kind of place where you might stop in for a quick slice and then end up sipping a Pizza Negroni on the roof three hours later. (There are worse ways to spend an afternoon…)
The restaurant serves pizza, pasta, and dishes from its wood-fired grill, while the adjoining shop offers homemade sauces and Italian provisions to bring a little of the experience home.
But here’s the real insider tip: Gioia is the only pizza spot on Wooster Street serving pizza by the slice. No commitment to an entire pie required. Grab one of the “Wooster Square” grandma-style Sicilian slices from the side-street gelato window, and while you’re there, finish with a pistachio gelato cone. The perfect balanced meal.
What to Order
- Wooster Square Slice: Grandma-style Sicilian pizza in cheese, pepperoni, or mashed potato.
- Pizza Negroni: A pizza-themed cocktail feels entirely appropriate at this point.
- Gelato: Pistachio, hazelnut, or espresso.
BAR
Pizza? Check. Brewery? Check. Nightclub? Also check.
BAR is a one-stop shop for anyone who wants dinner, drinks, and a night out without having to move their car. Honestly, it’s the perfect trifecta.
Originally a nightclub, BAR expanded into pizza in the late 1990s and has since become a New Haven staple, especially among the college crowd and anyone who thinks pizza tastes even better after a beer or two.
Unlike the coal-fired pies at some of the city’s historic institutions, BAR’s pizzas are cooked in a gas-fired oven, producing ultra-thin crusts with less of that signature char. The pies are sliced into long, narrow rectangles, making them ideal for sharing, snacking, or convincing yourself that six little pieces somehow count as one slice. (They absolutely do.) BAR also brews its own beer on-site, so there’s no shortage of options to pair with the pies.
And while there are plenty of toppings to choose from, the mashed potato pizza is the real star. Yes, mashed potatoes. On pizza. To some, it may sound sacrilegious. It shouldn’t work nearly as well as it does. But it does. It really, really does.
What to Order
- Mashed Potato and Bacon Pie: A white pie with garlic, mozzarella, mashed potatoes, and crispy bacon.
- Eggplant Parmesan Pie: A red pie loaded with extra sauce, Parmesan, mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, basil, garlic, and eggplant.
Modern Apizza
Rounding out our pilgrimage is Modern Apizza, because no proper New Haven pizza education is complete without visiting all three members of the city’s “Big Three.”
Founded in 1934 by Antonio “Tony” Tolli, Modern has been turning out its signature brick-oven pies for nearly a century. Unlike its coal-fired competitors, Modern uses an oil-fired oven, creating its own distinct take on the New Haven style.
The restaurant has changed hands over the decades but remains family-operated, with its longstanding recipes and neighborhood charm intact. Located away from the main Wooster Street drag, Modern has built a fiercely loyal following of its own. And that includes a few familiar faces, with Conan O’Brien, Steven Spielberg, and Phil Rosenthal among the famous visitors who’ve stopped by for a pie.
Together with Sally’s and Frank Pepe’s, Modern completes New Haven’s pizza holy trinity. Each has its own devoted fan base, its own signature style, and plenty of people willing to argue that theirs is the best. At this point, I was starting to understand why.
What to Order
- Broccoli and Cheese Pie: A red pie topped with broccoli and “mootz,” the local shorthand for mozzarella.